Susan Joy Carroll

Port Allegany - Susan Joy Carroll, 56, of Port Allegany, passed away on Sunday (May 3, 2020) at her residence.


She was born Feb. 4, 1964 in Clarksburg, WV, a daughter of Michael and Linda McCarty McCoy.  On May 18, 1989, in Clarksburg, WV, she married John H. Carroll, who survives.


Mrs. Carroll was a housewife tending to the needs of her family.


She loved being with her family.


In addition to her husband and parents, she is survived by:

Two daughters:  Mia McCarty of Port Allegany and Ashely (Leon) Sherwood of Turtlepoint

One son:  Tylor Carroll of Port Allegany

Five grandchildren:  Abbye, Kylee, Jonah, Tyler and Seth

Two sisters:  Cynthia Graves and Christina Martin, both of North Carolina

Four brothers:  Terry Wayne Paugh of Ohio, Michael McCoy, II of North Carolina, Mark Paugh of Florida and Daniel Paugh of Georgia

Aunt: Johnive McCarty of Port Allegany

And many nieces, nephews and great-nieces and great-nephews


Due to COVID-19 circumstances, there will be no visitation or services at this time. Services will be held at a later date.


Memorials, if desired, may be made to a charity of the donor’s choice.  Online condolences may be made at


Arrangements are under the direction of the Hartle-Tarbox Funeral Homes, Inc., Port Allegany.